Motion on fundamental dishonesty refused

A Defender’s attempt to have a Personal Injury Claim dismissed because of the Pursuer’s fundamental dishonesty was refused by a Judge in a recent Court of Session Action. In Grant Grubb v John Finlay [2017] CSOH 81 Mr Grubb raised a Personal Injury Action arising from a collision between his and another motor vehicle on a forecourt of a Tesco Petrol Station in Dundee. The Defender admitted liability but disputed the injury claim. Lord Kinclaven hearing the case refused the … Continued